Same Garmin S62, smarter buy: the black model saves you £130

Display

The display is effectively a tie. Both watches use the same 1.3-inch full-colour touchscreen, and both deliver the same map clarity, hole layout detail, yardages, and virtual caddie readouts. In practical terms, this matters because the S62’s screen is one of its biggest strengths: it is bright enough for sunny UK fairways and large enough to see green contours, hazards, and layup points without squinting. Since there is no difference in panel size, resolution, or interface, neither product wins here. For golfers who value quick distance checks and intuitive navigation, both are equally strong.

Performance

Performance is also a tie. These are the same Garmin Approach S62 hardware and software package, so you get the same GPS speed, same mapping responsiveness, and the same golf intelligence. The S62’s virtual caddie is useful because it factors in your typical distances, wind, elevation, and historical shot patterns to suggest a club, which is more helpful than a basic laser-style distance only when you want to build a smarter strategy. Garmin’s golf ecosystem is mature, with strong course mapping and dependable yardages, which is exactly what golfers need if they want to lower scores through better decisions. There is no performance advantage for either colourway.

Build quality and design

This is the one area where preference matters more than spec sheets. Both watches share the same premium construction, same rugged golf-first case, and same durable feel, but the white model has a cleaner, more standout look while the black model is more understated and versatile. For everyday wear, the black version is easier to pair with other clothing and looks less obviously like sporting equipment. For golfers who want a brighter, premium-looking watch on the course, the white version has more visual flair. Still, because build quality is identical, the design win is subjective rather than functional. Slight edge to Product B for everyday versatility.

Battery life

Battery life is a tie. Garmin quotes the same battery performance for both versions because the internals are identical, and that means the same golf round endurance and the same smartwatch usage expectations. For UK golfers, that is plenty for a full day at the club, multiple rounds in a week, and regular GPS use without constant charging. If you are comparing this to a launch monitor, battery life is not the same kind of metric, but it still matters: you want a watch that is ready to go when you are practising, playing, or reviewing data. No winner here.

Price and value for money

Product B wins comfortably. At £324.99, the black Garmin Approach S62 is £130.55 cheaper than the white version at £455.54, despite being the same watch with the same 4.5/5 rating from 2,540 reviews. That price gap is too large to justify on colour alone unless you specifically want the white finish. In value terms, the black model gives you the exact same GPS accuracy, virtual caddie, mapping, and premium experience for substantially less money. For golfers who want to spend wisely and put the savings toward lessons, a range session, or even a launch monitor rental, Product B is the smarter buy.

Game library/features

This is a tie, but it is worth understanding what you are actually getting. Both watches offer the same golf feature set: virtual caddie, hazard views, green view, shot tracking, pin positioning, and course mapping. Garmin’s golf watch ecosystem is one of the best for everyday course management because it helps you make better decisions before the shot, not just measure after the fact. While this is not a launch monitor and will not give you club delivery metrics like face angle, spin rate, or attack angle, it does give you the on-course data most golfers can actually use round to round. If your goal is smarter scoring rather than pure swing analysis, both products are equally capable.

Overall user experience

Overall, the black model is the better choice because the user experience is identical while the price is much lower. Both watches are easy to use, quick to read, and packed with features that genuinely help golfers manage the course better. The white version is attractive, but it does not offer any extra functionality, better battery life, improved accuracy, or added software compatibility. If you are buying for performance and value, the black S62 is the clear winner. If you are buying for aesthetics and want the white finish, you are paying a large premium for looks only.

Overall summary: Product B delivers the same premium Garmin S62 experience for £130.55 less, making it the definitive recommendation for most golfers. Product A only makes sense if the white finish is specifically worth the extra money to you.