Budget EV charging winner or smart solar-ready upgrade?
If you’re choosing between a low-cost portable EV charger and a pricier smart wallbox, the real question is not just price but how you’ll charge day to day. Product A is a portable 3-pin/commando-style solution with adjustable current and a carry bag, while Product B is a fixed smart wall charger with Wi‑Fi, solar charging support, and auto-lock. For UK drivers, that difference matters because home electricity costs, seasonal solar output, and how often you charge can change the economics fast. This comparison will help you decide which one actually fits your car, home, and budget.
AFYEEV EV Charger - Type 2 to 3 Pin Commando Plug, Adjustable Current 8/10/13/16/32A, 6Meter, IP65 Rated, 7.2kW, Delay Timer 1-12 Hours, Carry Bag Included
Masterplug Smart EV Home Wall Charger for Type 2 Electric and Plug-In Hybrid Vehicles, Socket Only, Mode 3, Auto-Lock, Solar Charging, Single Phase, Wi-Fi, Black, IP55, 7.4kW, 32A, EVCM3SS7B-MP
Our Recommendation
Masterplug wins overall because it is the better fit for a permanent UK home charging setup. The 7.4kW Mode 3 wallbox, Wi‑Fi control, auto-lock, and solar charging support give it a much stronger feature set and a more polished day-to-day experience. Product A is cheaper and portable, but if you are buying one charger for regular use at home, Product B is the more complete and future-proof choice.
Detailed Comparison
Display
Neither product is marketed as having a display in the traditional sense, so there is no screen-quality advantage to compare. Product A appears to be a straightforward portable charger with simple current adjustment and delay timer controls, while Product B focuses on smart connectivity through Wi‑Fi and app-based management rather than a display panel. Winner: tie, because neither product is defined by screen quality.
Performance
Product B wins on charging performance for most homeowners. It is a Mode 3 wall charger rated at 7.4kW and 32A, which is the standard fast home-charging setup in the UK for Type 2 EVs and plug-in hybrids. Product A is also rated around 7.2kW and 32A, but its adjustable current settings of 8/10/13/16/32A and 6-metre cable make it more flexible for portable use, not necessarily better for daily wall-mounted charging. If you want the most stable, repeatable home charging experience, Product B is the stronger performer; if you need to plug into different supplies and occasionally reduce current, Product A is more adaptable. Winner: Product B.
Build quality and design
Product B looks and feels like the more serious long-term installation. It is an IP55-rated wall unit with auto-lock, socket-only design, and single-phase Mode 3 operation, which is exactly what most UK homes need for a fixed charger. Product A is IP65-rated, which is actually better for dust and water resistance on paper, and the included carry bag makes it clearly designed for portability and transport. However, Product A’s portable nature also means more setup, more cable handling, and less of the neat, permanent finish many homeowners want. Winner: tie on raw protection, but Product B wins on overall home-install design, while Product A wins on portability.
Battery life
Strictly speaking, neither product has a battery, so this category is really about how well each charger supports your EV battery over time. Product B wins because smart wall chargers typically make it easier to manage charging habits, especially with solar charging support and auto-lock, which can encourage more controlled, regular top-ups. Product A’s delay timer 1–12 hours is useful if you want to shift charging into cheaper overnight UK electricity windows, but it lacks the broader automation and monitoring features that help you build better charging routines. For preserving convenience and avoiding unnecessary manual intervention, Product B is better. Winner: Product B.
Price and value for money
Product A is the clear value winner on upfront cost. At £127.04, it is £149.55 cheaper than Product B, which is a huge gap for essentially the same headline charging speed. For many UK drivers, especially those who only need a backup charger, occasional travel charging, or a simple way to plug into a commando socket, Product A offers strong value. Product B at £276.59 only makes sense if you will actually use the smart features, fixed installation, and solar integration. In pure pounds-per-kW terms, Product A wins comfortably. Winner: Product A.
Game library/features
These products do not have a game library, so the useful comparison is feature set. Product B wins decisively here: Wi‑Fi, solar charging support, auto-lock, socket-only Mode 3 operation, and a proper wall-mounted setup make it much more feature-rich. Product A’s feature list is practical rather than smart: adjustable current, 6-metre cable, IP65 rating, delay timer, and carry bag. That makes Product A versatile, but Product B is clearly the more advanced product for a connected home energy setup. Winner: Product B.
Overall user experience
Product A is best for simplicity, portability, and saving money. If you want a charger you can keep in the boot, use at different locations, or plug into a compatible commando supply without committing to a wall installation, it is easy to understand and hard to argue with at £127.04. Product B delivers the better everyday ownership experience for a UK home: it is a proper 7.4kW single-phase wallbox with Wi‑Fi and solar features, which matters if you want to charge from cheaper overnight rates or make use of surplus solar in spring and summer when UK generation is strongest. In winter, when solar output is low and charging often depends on the grid, the smart scheduling and auto-lock features become even more useful. Overall summary: Product A is the value buy, but Product B is the better long-term home charging solution for most EV owners.
Buy the AFYEEV EV Charger if...
Buy Product A if you want the cheapest route into home charging and you already have, or regularly use, a compatible 3-pin commando socket setup. It is also the better pick if portability matters, such as taking the charger with you for trips, second homes, or occasional use away from your main driveway. The adjustable current and delay timer are useful if you need to manage limited supply capacity or charge overnight on a budget.
Buy the Masterplug Smart EV if...
Buy Product B if you want a proper fixed home wall charger with smart features and solar integration. It is the better choice if you charge most days, want a tidier installation, or plan to use off-peak tariffs and surplus solar to cut running costs. If you value convenience, automation, and a more premium long-term setup, the Masterplug is the stronger buy.
Curated by The Electric Home on All The Top Picks
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.